Carriers · 22 compared
Carriers, ranked.
U.S. carriers
01 
→ 02 
→ 03 
→ 04 
→ 05 
→ 06 
→ 07 
→ 08 
→ 09 
→ 10 
→ 11 
→ 12 
→ 13 
→ 14 
→ 15 
→
Chubb
A global insurer specializing in high-net-worth personal lines and commercial/specialty coverage.
GEICO
A direct-to-consumer auto insurer and Berkshire Hathaway subsidiary, the third-largest U.S. auto insurer.
Travelers
Travelers insurance review: A++ (Superior) AM Best rating affirmed August 2026, auto and home sold online and through independent agents.
USAA
A member-owned insurer and financial-services provider serving the U.S. military community.
Allstate
A major U.S. personal-lines insurer selling through captive agents and direct channels.
Amica Mutual
The oldest mutual auto insurer in the U.S., focused on personal lines with a service-led model.
Auto-Owners Insurance
An agent-distributed insurer writing personal, commercial, and life lines across a multi-state footprint.
Progressive
A large U.S. auto insurer known for usage-based pricing and a leading commercial-auto book.
State Farm
The largest U.S. auto and home insurer, operating through a captive local-agent network.
The Hartford
A commercial-focused insurer that also provides AARP-endorsed auto and home insurance to consumers.
American Family
A Midwest-rooted mutual insurer writing personal, commercial, and life lines.
Erie Insurance
A super-regional insurer writing auto, home, life, and business lines through independent agents in a limited footprint.
Farmers Insurance
A large U.S. personal- and commercial-lines insurer distributing through exclusive and independent agents.
Liberty Mutual
A global property-casualty insurer writing broad personal and commercial lines (parent of Safeco).
Nationwide
A diversified mutual insurer and financial-services company writing personal, commercial, farm, and life lines.
Canadian carriers
Insurers that sell only in Canada. "NR" means we could not verify a published AM Best rating on the insurer's own site. In British Columbia, Saskatchewan and Manitoba, basic auto insurance comes from a public insurer.
01 
→ 02 
→ 03 
→ 04 
→ 05 
→ 06 
→ 07 
→
Intact Insurance
Canada's largest property and casualty insurer, selling car, home and business insurance through independent brokers.
The Co-operators
A Canadian co-operative insurer selling home, auto, life, travel, farm and business insurance through financial representatives.
Definity (Economical, Sonnet)
Canadian P&C group behind Economical Insurance (via brokers), Sonnet (direct online) and Family Insurance Solutions in BC.
Wawanesa Insurance
A Canadian mutual insurer founded in Manitoba in 1896, selling auto, home, farm and commercial insurance through brokers.
Aviva Canada
A Canadian subsidiary of UK-based Aviva plc, insuring home, auto, lifestyle and business risks for 2.5 million customers.
Desjardins Insurance
Insurance from Desjardins, Canada's largest cooperative financial group, selling car, home, RV, travel, life and pet insurance.
TD Insurance
The insurance arm of TD Bank Group, selling car, home, travel and life insurance direct to Canadians online and by phone.