Skip to content
Carriers · 15 compared

Carriers, ranked.

01
Chubb
A global insurer specializing in high-net-worth personal lines and commercial/specialty coverage.
Top pick
A++
AM BEST
02
GEICO
A direct-to-consumer auto insurer and Berkshire Hathaway subsidiary, the third-largest U.S. auto insurer.
Top pick
A++
AM BEST
03
Travelers
A large publicly traded property-casualty insurer with a major commercial and surety/bond business.
Top pick
A++
AM BEST
04
USAA
A member-owned insurer and financial-services provider serving the U.S. military community.
Top pick
A++
AM BEST
05
Allstate
A major U.S. personal-lines insurer selling through captive agents and direct channels.
Top pick
A+
AM BEST
06
Amica Mutual
The oldest mutual auto insurer in the U.S., focused on personal lines with a service-led model.
Top pick
A+
AM BEST
07
Auto-Owners Insurance
An agent-distributed insurer writing personal, commercial, and life lines across a multi-state footprint.
Top pick
A+
AM BEST
08
Progressive
A large U.S. auto insurer known for usage-based pricing and a leading commercial-auto book.
Top pick
A+
AM BEST
09
State Farm
The largest U.S. auto and home insurer, operating through a captive local-agent network.
Top pick
A+
AM BEST
10
The Hartford
A commercial-focused insurer that also provides AARP-endorsed auto and home insurance to consumers.
Top pick
A+
AM BEST
11
American Family
A Midwest-rooted mutual insurer writing personal, commercial, and life lines.
Solid
A
AM BEST
12
Erie Insurance
A super-regional insurer writing auto, home, life, and business lines through independent agents in a limited footprint.
Solid
A
AM BEST
13
Farmers Insurance
A large U.S. personal- and commercial-lines insurer distributing through exclusive and independent agents.
Solid
A
AM BEST
14
Liberty Mutual
A global property-casualty insurer writing broad personal and commercial lines (parent of Safeco).
Solid
A
AM BEST
15
Nationwide
A diversified mutual insurer and financial-services company writing personal, commercial, farm, and life lines.
Solid
A
AM BEST
Free quoteNo obligation · a few minutes
Get a quote